09 February 2017 Thursday
Kenya’s High Court on Thursday blocked the government’s decision to close the Dadaab refugee camp — the world’s largest — and force Somali refugees to return home.
Judge John Mativo ruled that the plan to shut down the camp was unconstitutional, violated Kenya’s international obligations and amounted to the persecution of refugees.
Dadaab is home to some 256,000 people, the vast majority of them Somalis who fled across the border following the outbreak of civil war in 1991. Many have lived there ever since.
The government unilaterally decided to close the camp in May last year, saying it was a terrorist training ground for Shabaab Islamist militants based in Somalia.
But Mativo ruled that a “decision specifically targeting Somali refugees is an act of group persecution, illegal, discriminatory and therefore unconstitutional”.
The shutdown was ordered without proper consultation of people affected by the decision, in violation of the constitutional right to fair legal proceedings, he said in his ruling.
“Hence the said decision is null and void,” he said.
He also blocked a government decision to disband Kenya’s Department for Refugee Affairs.
But the government later cautioned that it aimed to “strongly” appeal the ruling.
“We as a government have the cardinal responsibility of providing security for all Kenyans,” a statement said. “The camp had lost its humanitarian nature, and had become a haven for terrorism and other illegal activities.”.
Mativo also said the forced repatriation violated the 1951 United Nations Convention on refugees.
He was ruling on a challenge to the shutdown filed by the Kenya National Commission on Human Rights and rights group Kituo Cha Sheria.
Amnesty International’s East Africa chief Muthoni Wanyeki hailed Thursday’s outcome as “historic”.
“Today is a historic day for more than a quarter of a million refugees who were at risk of being forcefully returned to Somalia, where they would have been at serious risk of human rights abuses,” Wanyeki said.
“This ruling reaffirms Kenya’s constitutional and international legal obligation to protect people who seek safety from harm and persecution.”
The government caught refugees, aid groups, the United Nations and Kenya’s Western partners offguard last May when it announced plans to shut down the huge camp near the border, citing security concerns.
Since sending troops into neighboring Somalia in 2011, Kenya has come under repeated attack from Al-Qaeda-linked Shabaab militants.
The government has presented Dadaab as a security risk, saying Somali rebels inside the camp planned the Shabaab attacks at Nairobi’s Westgate shopping mall in 2013 and the Garissa university attack in 2015, though it has not provided evidence.
Authorities initially planned to close Dadaab at the end of November, but delayed the shutdown until May 2017 at the request of the UN refugee agency and against a backdrop of growing accusations of forced refugee returns to Somalia.
The UN High Commissioner for Refugees says the numbers have dwindled thanks to voluntary repatriations as well as resettlement in the Kakuma camp in northwest Kenya.
In September, Human Rights Watch warned in a report that the repatriation of Somalis violated international standards and that refugees were returning home involuntarily to face persecution and hunger.
Medical aid group Medecins Sans Frontieres (Doctors Without Borders) on Thursday welcomed the ruling as “a very positive step”.
It urged the government to consider “alternative solutions to long-term encampment on such a large scale,” including resettlement to third countries or to smaller camps in Kenya, or integration in Kenya.
Source: World Bulletin.